spacer
spacer search

Beth Sarim Community - A Place for People
A Place for People

Search
spacer
header
Verse of the day
Main Menu
Forum
- - - - - - -
About Beth Sarim
- - - - - - -
Articles
Beth Sarim Articles
2001 Translation
- - - - - - -
Downloads
Links
- - - - - - -
Site info
Contacts
- - - - - - -
JW Reform Section
JW Reform
2001 Translation Section
2001 Translation
- - - - - - -
Administrator
Who's Online
 
Forum arrow Forum

Bethsarim Community Forum  


What are you doing for the memorial this year? - 2005/03/21 00:12 What follows assumes that everyone who comes here genuinely loves truth. And if you love truth, you won’t be inclined to cower or run away the instant your beliefs are put under scrutiny.

Also, what follows was originally intended for a different website. But due to timing and other matters, I’ve chosen to present an abbreviated version here. So, here goes.

The memorial of Christ’s death is without doubt the most significant celebration on our calendar.

We owe it to Jehovah, the God of Truth, to get it right. And we owe it to His son to celebrate this event in the manner he intended.

Yet, as Jehovah’s Witnesses, we’ve saddled this event with unscriptural and irrelevant trappings. For example, precisely where in the Bible does it say anything about “observers?”

Search the Bible. Jesus did not bring along “observers” to watch the Apostles partake. Nowhere in Paul’s writings does he say anything about “observers.” Neither is that idea found in the former Passover celebrations. You simply won’t find that idea anywhere in the Bible.
People either shared in the meal, or they didn’t attend. It’s as simple as that.

And nowhere does the Bible make provision for those who are partakers of the Lord’s evening meal to be presided over by those who are not partakers.

The entire “observer” scenario is a contrivance of the Watchtower Society. It’s a hangover from the pre-1930’s when everyone was expected to partake. From 1935 onwards, the Society decided that those who didn’t partake should just quietly sit and observe.

Of course, “observers” were then in the minority. And those taking the lead back then didn’t expect this system of things to last so long. Yet here we are 70 years later and the situation is reversed.

There are now millions of “observers” and only a hand-full of partakers. And still the Society sticks to its outdated and irrelevant teachings. In the process, they’ve turned the Memorial into an embarrassing sideshow for the few genuine partakers and their family members.

Only a miniscule number of the 96,000+ congregations have any anointed in them. And those few congregations with anointed become hotbeds of gossip as the mandatory “is he or isn’t he” discussion kicks in. Is this they way Jesus intended for his death to be commemorated?

Again, it makes absolutely no sense to pressure millions of people into attending a celebratory meal, yet bar them from sharing in it.

Now we’re definitely not suggesting that everyone should partake. Far from it. What we’re saying is that the Bible only makes provision for those in the New Covenant to partake, so logically they are the only ones that should attend.

The point is this: If you're not a partaker, then Scripturally, you're not obligated to attend as an “observer.” If you want to attend a Kingdom Hall that’s fine. But you don’t need to feel guilty about not attending. Attending as an “observer” is not synonymous with worshipping in Spirit and Truth.

Besides, the time is fast approaching when few genuine anointed will be found celebrating the Memorial in Kingdom Halls anyway.

Meantime, there are plenty of other ways to show respect for everything Christ accomplished by his faithfulness and death. Let your love for him determine how you personally do that this year.

Peace and Love
V
  | | The topic has been locked.
Re:What are you doing for the memorial this year? - 2005/03/21 01:54 Hi Victor. Some interesting thoughts. It's certainly true the Bible doesn't speak of observers. And I have seen the pantomine that can occur with the whispered debates among observers about who 'is' and who 'can't be' anointed, the stares and gawping that sometimes occurs. I know that many anointed ones have come to find the memorial at the KHs to be quite an ordeal. Which is so sad.

We might also consider what it is like to drink from a glass that has been used by, say, three congregations (who share the same hall) and handled by every 'observer' (hundreds) of them, including sticky fingered children, as it is passed to and fro and which finally arrives in the hands of an anointed one who can barely bring thmeselves to drink from this now visibly filthy, smeared, glass. I have known that to occur.

In your post Victor you say. "we're saying" and "we're not saying" etc. Can I ask who the "we" is?

Much Philia.

Phi.

Post edited by: Phi, at: 2005/03/21 01:58
  | | The topic has been locked.
Re:What are you doing for the memorial this year? - 2005/03/21 07:45 I hear you loud and clear brother. I am going to the memorial this year at the hall and partake. I hate the fact that instead of enjoying the lords meal, I will feel like a sideshow attraction. All eyes will be on me. There is one another anointed sister in the hall but she has partaken since the 80's and still feels uncomfortable. I think this will be the last time I partake at the hall anyways. I feel I will probably not last until next year. So I will make my showing this year because I want people to know that I am not afraid to show who I am and what my hope is. It is too bad that it has become like this. The WT has divide the anointed in many ways but I guess thats how it is supposed to be.

This new book is quite clear that things are only going to get worse and the sheep will become more scattered. It is a good thing that we listen to our master and not to some supposed visible channel of God which has made itself and Idol. This is so very much emphasized in this book. They are drawing everyone in to trust in them and not God. It is really sad. I feel very upset about it. It makes my stomach turn. Instead of focusing our attention on trusting Jehovah and Christ alone. It is all about how we must trust them because trusting them is like trusting God.

Trusting in men is relative. You can only trust men to the point when they can no longer be trusted. All men are liars and fall short. This does not mean all men are bad but that we can only put so much trust in any man. Our trust must be in God and Christ and God's word. His word is the only true guidance we have today. The things men have done to help us understand God's word can be very helpful but once we have matured then as Paul said we must use are own perseptive powers to distinguish right from wrong.
  | | The topic has been locked.
Re:What are you doing for the memorial this year? - 2005/03/21 07:50 Hello V

Victory wrote:
Now we’re definitely not suggesting that everyone should partake. Far from it. What we’re saying is
V


I, too, wondered who the 'we' is ...

Peace ... Shiloah
  | | The topic has been locked.
Re:What are you doing for the memorial this year? - 2005/03/21 07:56 Shai

Thanks for your comments. What I've written is actually part of a much longer, indepth article. I hope to post the complete reasoning on another website in the future.

Also, I've posted another article here. The other article is specifically intended for the anointed. Again, it's brief, the intention being that an expanded and detailed article will appear elsewhere later.

It's just that we're getting close to the memorial and I felt compelled to get this stuff out.

Phi

Thanks for your observations. I'm having to go to work now. Will answer your questions later.

All the best

V
  | | The topic has been locked.
Re:What are you doing for the memorial this year? - 2005/03/21 11:52 Victory just to put some perspective on the discussion I wonder if you can explain why there were not "observers" in the first century while most if not all had the heavenly hope. Now that we have those that do not have the heavenly hope how is it you say the first century sets the stage for how it should be accomplished?

Intresting perspective. I have heard some say they think all should partake. I disagree with that too.

peace to you,
Mars

Post edited by: polemotheos, at: 2005/03/21 11:53
Your Peace, Surrender, In You,
YHVH Re-connect Co-operative
  | | The topic has been locked.
spacer
Latest Posts
1914 No longer

See why the thinking about the gentile times and 1914 is wrong.

Click here to see the presentation.

To view timeline speculations based on Jubilee Calculations see here

Statistics
Members: 177
News: 75
WebLinks: 16
Visitors: 638253

 
© 2009 Beth Sarim Community - A Place for People
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.
spacer